Brewers Face Tough Decision on Injured Star Woodruff

Brandon Woodruff, a prominent figure for the Milwaukee Brewers, stands at a crossroads this offseason as he approaches free agency. Having missed the entirety of the 2024 season due to a shoulder injury, his future with the team is uncertain.

Woodruff's performance on the mound has historically been stellar, marked by a 2.98 ERA in limited innings pitched in prior seasons. However, the severity of his injury initially suggested it might jeopardize his 2026 and 2027 campaigns. Fortunately, surgery was averted, and he has recently been throwing, offering a glimmer of hope for a return.

Despite his significant contributions when healthy, Woodruff's substantial salary and extended absence present a complex decision for the Brewers. He holds the second-highest salary, exceeding $22 million in 2026, with only Christian Yelich having a comparable contract among core players.

While a return in 2026 is not assured and might necessitate a deep playoff run, the possibility of his presence in 2027 remains. The Brewers are contemplating whether to re-sign him, likely at a significantly reduced price. His value extends beyond his pitching prowess, encompassing leadership and his status as a homegrown, beloved athlete within the organization and the Milwaukee community.