Whitby's Whale Bone Arch Faces Costly Replacement Dilemma

Whitby's iconic Whale Bone Arch, a landmark for over 170 years, faces a significant replacement cost, potentially exceeding £60,000. North Yorkshire Council has confirmed that sourcing genuine whale bones for the structure has been exhausted, presenting ethical and legal challenges.

Various replacement options are being considered, each with a different price tag and lifespan. Coating the existing bones in glass-reinforced plastic is estimated at £30,000 but offers a temporary fix. More durable alternatives include hardwood replicas for approximately £20,000, expected to last around 100 years, or stainless steel mesh replicas for £30,000.

The most robust and enduring solution proposed is casting replacements in bronze, which would cost around £60,000. This option guarantees an indefinite lifespan and eliminates current timber fixing issues. Whitby Town Council, as the owner and manager, is consulting on the findings before North Yorkshire Council makes a final decision on design, procurement, and funding.