Is proposing on Christmas morning a good idea?

Proposing on Christmas morning can be very romantic if done thoughtfully, but it depends on the couple's preferences and the specific circumstances, like gift-giving.

Should an engagement ring count as a Christmas gift?

Generally, an engagement ring is considered a separate momentous occasion, and it is customary for partners to still exchange Christmas gifts.

What are the red flags in a proposal?

A red flag in a proposal could be if one partner sees it as a transaction or a way to avoid other obligations, such as not providing a Christmas gift.

Home / Lifestyle / Christmas Proposal Fury: Ring Replaces All Gifts

Christmas Proposal Fury: Ring Replaces All Gifts

10 Dec, 2025

•

Summary

Man proposes on Christmas, claims ring is girlfriend's gift.
Online debate erupts over whether the proposal is romantic.
Critics call the groom's attitude a potential red flag.

Christmas Proposal Fury: Ring Replaces All Gifts

A man's plan to propose on Christmas morning has led to significant backlash online. He intends to present his girlfriend with an engagement ring, stating it will be her only Christmas gift this year due to its expense. This decision has divided opinion, with many arguing that a proposal should be a joyous step forward, not a substitute for traditional holiday presents.

The friend who shared the story expressed concern, noting that the girlfriend is a wonderful person who deserves more. While the proposal itself is described as fitting for the girlfriend's personality, the idea of the ring replacing all other gifts has been widely criticized. Online commenters have called the groom's reasoning "distasteful" and "embarrassing."