Deadly Bacteria Found in Popular Cream Cheese

Consumers are urged to exercise extreme caution following an urgent recall of 14 flavors of Made Fresh Salads cream cheeses. The recall was initiated due to fears that the popular spreads may be contaminated with listeria, a deadly bacterium. These products, packaged in 5lb white plastic tubs, were distributed directly to retail stores in Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and the broader New York City area, with a best-before date of February 27.

While no illnesses have been reported as of February 23, 2026, health officials are advising individuals experiencing warning signs to contact their healthcare providers. Listeria infection, known as listeriosis, can cause severe symptoms in healthy adults, including high fever and headaches, and can be life-threatening for young children, the elderly, and those with weakened immune systems, potentially leading to sepsis or brain swelling.

The manufacturer discovered the contamination during routine testing for microorganisms. The presence of listeria was identified on a mixer within the manufacturing line, which has since been removed. This is not the first recall for the company, as their Macaroni Salad and Tuna Deluxe Salad products were also recalled in November of the previous year due to listeria contamination.

Stores are instructed to discard the affected tubs or return them for a full refund. Consumers who have purchased the recalled cream cheeses are encouraged to contact the company directly. The FDA has raised the alarm, highlighting the serious health risks associated with listeria, which can survive at low temperatures and is often found in various food products.