Oregon Infant Battles Botulism From Donated Formula

A 10-month-old boy in Portland, Oregon, is battling infant botulism following consumption of contaminated ByHeart baby formula, which had been donated to assist low-income and homeless families. Ashaan Carter's mother received the formula from a state caseworker in early November, shortly before a national recall was issued for all ByHeart products due to potential contamination. The 27-year-old mother had been exclusively breastfeeding but accepted the donated formula when her milk supply diminished, leading to her son's severe illness.

Following the formula's consumption, Ashaan developed severe constipation and muscle weakness, requiring hospitalization and diagnosis with infant botulism. He has since been hospitalized twice, is reliant on a feeding tube due to persistent muscle weakness, and is relearning basic motor skills like crawling and talking. This situation has raised significant concerns about the safety of products distributed to vulnerable populations through social services and donation programs.

ByHeart had partnered with various nonprofits, including Baby2Baby, to distribute nearly 24,000 cans of formula nationwide since March 2022. Despite efforts to recall the product, some had already reached families. Legal action is underway, with over 30 families represented by Seattle lawyer Bill Marler, and at least 18 lawsuits filed against ByHeart. No new cases have been reported since December 17, 2026, and ByHeart's production remains shut down.