Ancient Oak Felled Despite Being Healthy: Restaurant Faces Backlash

A 500-year-old oak tree, residing in Enfield, north London, was felled in April 2025, sparking significant controversy. Toby Carvery's owners, Mitchell and Butlers, initially stated that contractors removed the tree based on expert advice, citing it as dying and a public hazard.

However, Enfield Council's subsequent inspection in December 2024 revealed the oak was healthy and posed no danger. A Forestry Commission report corroborated this, finding no major diseases and noting the trunk's integrity, with evidence of wildlife inhabiting a cavity.

The incident has led to backlash, with the local council initiating eviction proceedings against Mitchells & Butlers for severe lease violations. The ancient tree, a historical landmark that survived centuries of change, is considered an irreplaceable part of Enfield's natural heritage.

Campaigners have likened the destruction to the felling of Sycamore Gap, estimating the Enfield oak's ecological value at a million pounds. They have urged the Metropolitan Police to investigate, though the force has largely deemed it a civil matter, with the council pursuing lease forfeiture.

Councillor Tim Leaver of Enfield Council condemned the felling as a 'reckless act' and a 'serious breach of the lease.' The council is demanding a public apology, financial reparations, and compensation for incurred costs, emphasizing accountability for the irreversible damage to the ancient Whitewebbs Oak.