What is the proposal for Duxbury Reef?

An environmental group is proposing to redesignate Duxbury Reef as a fully protected State Marine Reserve, which would include a ban on all fishing.

Why are some people concerned about the Duxbury Reef fishing ban?

Concerns include the loss of recreational fishing opportunities, the impact on local businesses that rely on locally caught fish, and a perceived lack of community engagement in the decision-making process.

When will there be more information on the Duxbury Reef proposal?

The California Department of Fish and Wildlife plans to release a draft evaluation by March, and the State Fish and Game Commission will hold a public listening session on April 21.

Home / Environment / Shale Reef Fishing Ban Sparks Fierce Debate

Shale Reef Fishing Ban Sparks Fierce Debate

30 Jan

•

Summary

Proposal seeks to ban all fishing at Duxbury Reef.
Environmental group wants to triple protected reef area.
Local businesses fear economic impact from fishing ban.

Shale Reef Fishing Ban Sparks Fierce Debate

An environmental organization, the Environmental Action Committee of West Marin, is advocating for enhanced protections at Duxbury Reef, one of North America's largest shale reefs. Their proposal includes redesignating the area as a fully protected State Marine Reserve, which would necessitate a complete ban on all fishing activities.

This proposal aims to expand the protected territory threefold and concerns the reef and a 1,000-foot zone around its low-tide line for an eight-mile stretch. Proponents argue this will safeguard vulnerable intertidal species, like octopus, and reduce confusion regarding regulations. They also note that the petition garnered broad support from various stakeholders when initially submitted.

However, the proposal has met with significant local opposition. Anglers express concerns about losing a valued recreational activity and its role in fostering appreciation for the reef. Local businesses also voice worries about the economic repercussions, particularly restaurants that feature locally caught fish and highlight their connection to the local economy. Marin County Supervisor Dennis Rodoni has even withdrawn his initial support, calling for more community engagement.