Which US states have the strictest phone-free school policies according to the Becca Schmill Foundation?

North Dakota and Rhode Island have the strictest policies, requiring phones to be inaccessible all day.

Why are schools banning cellphones based on The Anxious Generation?

Bans aim to combat the 'chronically online' condition, improve mental health, and boost academic performance.

What is a 'bell-to-bell' phone policy in schools?

A bell-to-bell policy requires students to keep personal electronic devices inaccessible throughout the entire school day.

Home / Education / Schools Go Phone-Free: Only 2 States Score A+

Schools Go Phone-Free: Only 2 States Score A+

21 Jan

•

Summary

Two states enforce strict bell-to-bell phone bans for students.
A new report grades states on their cellphone policies in schools.
Many students struggle with the 'chronically online' condition.

Schools Go Phone-Free: Only 2 States Score A+

A recent analysis reveals that only North Dakota and Rhode Island have enacted gold-standard policies for phone-free schools, mandating students keep devices inaccessible all day. This "bell-to-bell" approach is considered crucial by experts like Lina Nealon of the Institute for Families and Technology.

Seventeen states and Washington D.C. earned a "B" for having bell-to-bell policies with more accessible phone storage. Conversely, eight states only ban phones during instruction, receiving a "C." Despite growing support for restrictions, some states have not yet enacted laws, citing a desire for local control, though advocates argue it's a public health issue.

Supporters believe these strict laws can enhance academic performance, student well-being, and school community. However, concerns persist, including student pushback and arguments that phones are essential for emergencies, calculators, or focus. These opposing views highlight the ongoing debate surrounding student cellphone use in educational settings.