Home / Crime and Justice / Vancouver Starbucks stabbing: Manslaughter conviction for smoking dispute
Vancouver Starbucks stabbing: Manslaughter conviction for smoking dispute
4 Sep
Summary
- Man convicted of manslaughter for fatal stabbing outside Vancouver Starbucks.
- Confrontation began over smoking cannabis near the café's entrance.
- Judge ruled actions exceeded self-defense, despite fear for life.
Inderdeep Singh Gosal has been convicted of manslaughter for the fatal stabbing of Paul Schmidt, which occurred during a confrontation over smoking outside a Vancouver Starbucks on March 26, 2023. Gosal was acquitted of second-degree murder but has remained in custody since his arrest.
The altercation originated when Schmidt objected to Gosal smoking cannabis near the café's entrance. The situation turned violent when Schmidt approached Gosal, who subsequently produced a knife from his hoodie. CCTV footage indicated Schmidt initiated the physical confrontation by advancing on Gosal.
Gosal stabbed Schmidt multiple times, leading to Schmidt collapsing within seconds. The judge found that while Gosal may have feared for his life, his use of the knife extended beyond the bounds of self-defense, occurring in the heat of the moment.
Evidence presented at trial included Gosal's statements to police, "I did it. He came after me." The court also heard about Gosal's history of schizophrenia and inconsistencies in his testimony regarding the knife, alcohol consumption, and his mental state, which led to reasonable doubt for the murder charge.
