Comatose Inmate Restrained: Prison Staff Criticised

Prison staff have faced severe criticism for their handling of a 74-year-old inmate, Malcolm MacDougal, who was found comatose at HMP Full Sutton on September 30, 2024, after consuming synthetic cannabis. A subsequent report from the Prisons and Probation Ombudsman highlighted significant failings, including a 16-minute delay in calling for an ambulance. The report also questioned the dignity afforded to the inmate due to the use of restraints, which continued even during medical procedures.

MacDougal, who had been serving a life sentence since 1982 and was on a care plan for various health issues, was pronounced dead on the same day he was taken ill. Staff defended the use of restraints, citing his history of substance misuse. However, the ombudsman stressed that restraining a comatose individual reflects poorly on the facility and recommended that staff prioritize a prisoner's medical condition and actual risk. The report also noted previous concerns at HMP Full Sutton regarding inadequate risk assessments and inappropriate restraint use.

In response to the findings, the Prison Service accepted the ombudsman's recommendations. They confirmed that HMP Full Sutton has since enhanced its emergency response protocols and reinforced guidance on the use of restraints. Support for prisoners with substance misuse issues has also been strengthened as part of the improvements implemented.