Home / Crime and Justice / Deputy Accused of Arson, Attempted Murder on Duty
Deputy Accused of Arson, Attempted Murder on Duty
18 Jun
Summary
- Deputy Alshaman is accused of setting fire to a residence with people inside.
- The trial continues with witness testimony, including the child's mother.
- Prosecutors allege financial motives for the alleged crimes.
The trial for Aaron Alshaman, an Oneida County sheriff's deputy, entered its fourth day on June 18, 2026, with continued witness testimony. Alshaman, 29, is accused of setting fire to a Utica residence on April 9, 2025, while on duty and allegedly intending to harm multiple occupants, including his infant son.
Jennifer Gudnaya, the infant's mother, testified about text messages exchanged with Alshaman that preceded her seeking full custody and legal action. She called 911 after being overcome by smoke and fleeing the residence with her child and parents.
District Attorney Todd Carville stated that financial matters were the motive behind the alleged arson and attempted murder. The defense, however, claims the prosecution's case is circumstantial and argues against the alleged motive being over child support payments.
Alshaman, who has a history with the Oneida County Sheriff's Office and the Rome Police Department, pleaded not guilty to all charges. If convicted of the top charge, second-degree arson, he faces up to 25 years in state prison.
