Home / Crime and Justice / Mushroom Killer's Appeal Denied: Life Sentence Stands
Mushroom Killer's Appeal Denied: Life Sentence Stands
30 Oct
Summary
- Erin Patterson's murder convictions were upheld on appeal.
- The court ruled she will never be released from prison.
- Patterson poisoned three relatives with a mushroom-laced meal.
Erin Patterson, convicted of murder and attempted murder for serving a toxic mushroom meal, has had her appeal against the convictions dismissed. The Court of Appeal in Victoria ruled that her crimes were 'extraordinarily cold and calculated,' warranting the strongest denouncement.
The court determined that Patterson, 51, should never be released from prison, overturning the previous life sentence that allowed for a non-parole period. She was found guilty of murdering her in-laws, Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, by poisoning their beef Wellington with death cap mushrooms in 2023.
Patterson was also convicted of attempting to murder Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, who survived the poisoning but suffers ongoing health issues. Her legal team had argued several grounds for appeal, including issues with jury accommodation and the admissibility of evidence. However, all seven grounds were dismissed by the appeal judges.
While Patterson has 28 days to consider seeking an appeal to the High Court of Australia, her bid to overturn the convictions has definitively failed. The court emphasized the shocking nature of her criminality, making it inappropriate to fix any non-parole period.
