What kind of proof do investigators need to show Nancy Guthrie is alive?

A private investigator suggests that a video of Nancy Guthrie answering personal questions only she would know would be more convincing than a simple photograph.

Why is sending ransom notes to the media instead of the family a mistake?

Sending ransom notes to news outlets instead of directly to the family is considered a 'rookie mistake' by investigators, as it bypasses expected communication channels in such cases.

What do authorities believe about Nancy Guthrie's current status?

Authorities, including the Pima County Sheriff, believe Nancy Guthrie is still alive and was taken from her home against her will, and they are operating under this assumption.

Home / Crime and Justice / Kidnappers' Rookie Mistake: No Family Contact in Missing Woman Case

Kidnappers' Rookie Mistake: No Family Contact in Missing Woman Case

7 Feb

•

Summary

Investigator suggests video is needed to prove woman is alive.
Ransom notes sent to media, not family, a potential 'rookie' error.
Authorities believe woman is still alive and held nearby.

Kidnappers' Rookie Mistake: No Family Contact in Missing Woman Case

A private investigator specializing in kidnapping cases has outlined what would be required to prove the safety of Nancy Guthrie, who has been missing from her Tucson, Arizona, home since January 31. Logan Clarke stated that any proof of life must go beyond simple photos, suggesting a video of Ms. Guthrie answering personal questions would be more convincing.

Investigators are proceeding under the assumption that Ms. Guthrie, 84, is still alive. Forensic teams recently discovered a camera on her roof. The Pima County Sheriff also expressed belief that she was taken against her will and remains alive, stating he would not assume otherwise without physical evidence to the contrary.

Complicating the investigation are multiple ransom notes sent to news stations rather than the Guthrie family. These notes reportedly contained specific monetary demands and deadlines, including one for February 9. Experts consider this direct communication with media a significant misstep by the alleged abductors, noting that no one claiming to hold Ms. Guthrie has contacted the family directly.