Home / Crime and Justice / Judge Slams 'Outrageous' Forensic Backlog
Judge Slams 'Outrageous' Forensic Backlog
27 Jan
Summary
- A judge called a six-month trial delay 'outrageous'.
- The delay is due to a significant backlog in DNA evidence.
- Forensic Science Queensland faces years of testing backlogs.
A Queensland judge has vehemently criticized a minimum six-month delay in an attempted murder trial, labeling the situation "simply outrageous." The trial of John Ikundu Karanja, accused of stabbing a masseuse in the neck in July 2024, was postponed because Forensic Science Queensland cannot provide a DNA statement until at least June, potentially September.
Justice Peter Davis expressed dismay, noting the increasing importance of DNA evidence over three decades. The delay stems from a critical failure within the state's DNA lab, which has resulted in a years-long backlog. This backlog has necessitated the re-examination of DNA evidence from major crime cases over the past 2.5 years due to contamination issues.
The defense confirmed that bail was not a viable option for Karanja, who faces attempted murder and attempted rape charges, due to immigration detention concerns. The judge adjourned the trial to a date yet to be fixed, with Karanja remaining in custody as the forensic backlog impacts the judicial process.
