Home / Crime and Justice / Justice for Isla Bell? Family Protests Dropped Charge
Justice for Isla Bell? Family Protests Dropped Charge
16 May
Summary
- Manslaughter charge dropped against man accused of Isla Bell's death.
- Family and supporters protested at Victorian state library.
- Bell's mother criticized the legal system's protection of victims.

A protest took place at the Victorian state library on Saturday, organized by supporters of Isla Bell. The 19-year-old's body was discovered in a Melbourne tip approximately 18 months prior to the event. Demonstrators voiced their opposition to prosecutors dropping a manslaughter charge against Marat Ganiev, 55, who had initially been accused of murdering Bell in October 2024. Prosecutors cited insufficient evidence for a trial as the reason for withdrawing the manslaughter charge. Ganiev has since been charged with attempting to pervert the course of justice. Bell's mother, Justine Spokes, expressed profound grief and frustration with the legal system, which she described as 'sick and perverted.' She highlighted perceived flaws in the system designed to protect vulnerable women. Despite her pain, Spokes urged a focus on love and addressing systemic issues like misogyny in Australia. She noted that her daughter had endured prior 'horrors at the hands of really unwell men' before the incident that led to her death. Bell's remains were found in a refrigerator at a Dandenong rubbish tip in November 2024. Eyal Yaffe, who was also accused of assisting an offender, had his charges withdrawn and was released. David, Bell's grandfather, called for intervention from the Victorian attorney general, emphasizing a community need for conversation about justice rather than vengeance.