Home / Crime and Justice / Killer's Execution Nears 35 Years After Brutal Florida Keys Murder
Killer's Execution Nears 35 Years After Brutal Florida Keys Murder
18 Nov
Summary
- Killer will be executed 35 years after the brutal murder.
- Couple's unborn son died when his mother stopped breathing.
- Killer's DNA matched semen found at the crime scene.

Florida is preparing to execute Thomas Mitchell Overton, who murdered Missy and Mike MacIvor and their unborn son 35 years ago. The couple was preparing their home's nursery for their son, Kyle Patrick, when Overton broke in on August 21, 1991. Missy, who was eight months pregnant, and Mike were both killed, with their unborn child dying shortly after his mother.
Overton, who had met Missy at a gas station, was later linked to the crime through DNA evidence. Despite his claims of innocence and defense arguments of planted evidence, Overton was convicted and sentenced to death. His execution on November 19, 2026, will be Florida's record 20th execution this year.
Missy and Mike MacIvor were described as a vibrant couple deeply in love and excited about starting their family. Mike was an inventor and pilot, while Missy, a former babysitter and volunteer, was set to begin teaching third grade. Their vibrant future was tragically cut short by Overton's violent actions.