Home / Crime and Justice / Family Claims Detention Center Death Was Murder
Family Claims Detention Center Death Was Murder
23 Nov, 2025
Summary
- Sister believes David Caldwell was strangled, citing neck and arm bruising.
- Inmate reportedly told David was beaten by staff in the shower.
- Inquest concluded death was natural from asthma; abuse allegations questioned.

David Caldwell, who was 18 when sentenced for minor theft offences in 1981, may have died from foul play at Medomsley detention centre. His sister, Carol Kyle, stated there was clear evidence of strangulation, noting significant bruising on his neck and arms. She also revealed an inmate informed her that David had been assaulted by staff shortly before his death.
An official report indicated David was examined upon arrival and found to be healthy. However, during a visit, his sister observed bruising on his face and legs, which David attributed to 'the screws' for not complying. His death on January 12, 1982, less than a month after arrival, was officially attributed to respiratory failure from an asthma attack, a conclusion his family disputes.




