Home / Crime and Justice / Bombay HC Rules: Old-Grant Land Belongs to Union

Bombay HC Rules: Old-Grant Land Belongs to Union

Summary

  • Old-grant land in Pune belongs to the Union government.
  • Construction on such land doesn't grant ownership rights.
  • Trust failed to establish absolute title to the Pune property.

The Bombay High Court recently declared that land granted under old-grant conditions in Pune remains the property of the Union government. The court overturned a lower court's possession decree concerning a bungalow in Pune Cantonment, stating that construction on such plots does not grant occupants ownership rights. A private trust's claim to absolute title over the property was deemed unsubstantiated, rendering their eviction notice invalid. This pivotal ruling, made on November 18, distinguishes between owning land and possessing structures on old-grant properties.

The dispute centered on 0.85 acres in Pune Cantonment, including a bungalow. The T S Anklesaria Trust asserted ownership based on a 1918 sale deed. However, the Union government contended the land was granted under the 1827 Govt General Order (GGO), reserving proprietary rights. The High Court examined historical documents, including the General Land Register, classifying the property as Class B-3 land with the trust's predecessor holding only occupancy rights. The court emphasized that a sale deed can only transfer existing title, not create a superior one.

Further reinforcing its decision, the court referenced the 1827 GGO, which explicitly states that building permissions on land within military cantonments do not transfer land ownership. The land continues to belong to the state and is resumable by the government. Historical records and correspondence indicated that only occupancy rights, subject to government conditions, had been transferred. The trust's failure to prove the source of their vendor's title and challenge the GLR entry further weakened their claim.

Disclaimer: This story has been auto-aggregated and auto-summarised by a computer program. This story has not been edited or created by the Feedzop team.

Read more news on

Property Code: 5571