Spotify's Stock Stumbles Despite Record Growth

Spotify recently announced stellar Q3 results, surpassing 700 million monthly active users and achieving a gross margin of 31.6%. The company also generated €806 million in free cash flow in that quarter alone. Growth is being driven by a robust free tier, global premium subscriber increases, enhanced user engagement, and continuous product evolution, including features like lossless audio and AI integrations.

Despite these strong business fundamentals, Spotify's stock has underperformed, trading significantly below its mid-2025 highs. The market's caution is rooted in several factors. A key concern is stagnant average revenue per user (ARPU), which declined 4% year-over-year due to a greater mix of discounted plans and growth in lower-priced markets. Additionally, Spotify's advertising revenue experienced a 6% year-over-year decline in Q3, indicating challenges in ad pricing and execution.

Furthermore, Spotify faces structural limitations that temper investor enthusiasm. Its gross margins, while improving, are considerably lower than software companies due to substantial payouts to rights holders. The company also contends with intense competition from major tech players like Apple, Amazon, and Google, who can leverage music streaming as a loss-leader. This competitive landscape limits Spotify's pricing power and ability to significantly increase ad loads.

Investors are currently favoring tech companies with clear AI advantages, strong platform leverage, and high-margin software models, seeking exponential growth rather than steady expansion. Spotify's model, which involves significant content costs and less operating leverage, does not fit this narrative, leading to a disconnect between its operational success and stock market valuation.