Home / Business and Economy / Elevance Health Sues CMS Over Medicare Ratings
Elevance Health Sues CMS Over Medicare Ratings
4 Jul
Summary
- Elevance Health sued CMS over Medicare Advantage star rating recalculations.
- Company claims different processes cost it $115 million in bonus payments.
- Dispute centers on regulatory consistency and future payment impacts.

Elevance Health has initiated legal proceedings against the Centers for Medicare & CMS, challenging the methodology used for recalculating Medicare Advantage star ratings. The health insurer asserts that the agency applied distinct processes to Elevance when compared to Clover Health.
This discrepancy, according to Elevance Health, led to a substantial financial impact, costing the company approximately $115 million in lost bonus payments. The core of the dispute revolves around the principle of regulatory consistency in how quality scores are determined.
This legal battle underscores Elevance Health's reliance on stable and predictable Medicare Advantage rules. The court's decision on the CMS process could have far-reaching implications, affecting not only Elevance Health but also setting precedents for other insurers regarding the stability of star ratings and associated revenue streams.