Home / Arts and Entertainment / 5 Seconds of Summer Grapple with Pop-Punk Identity as Genre Evolves
5 Seconds of Summer Grapple with Pop-Punk Identity as Genre Evolves
3 Aug
Summary
- 5 Seconds of Summer questioned if they "fit" the nostalgic pop-punk lineup at When We Were Young Festival
- Producer Andrew Goldstein explains the similarities between pop and pop-punk that allow for crossover success
- Paramore and Fall Out Boy faced backlash from fans when they evolved their sound, but paved the way for future artists
In August 2025, the pop-punk band 5 Seconds of Summer found themselves in a peculiar position. When invited to perform at the nostalgic When We Were Young Festival, they were initially eager to take the stage alongside their musical influences like Yellowcard and Sum 41. However, as their enthusiasm waned, the band members began to question whether they truly "fit" the lineup.
Guitarist Michael Clifford explains that 5 Seconds of Summer have long grappled with their genre classification, unsure if they are an "alternative band," "pop stars," "rock musicians," or a "boy band." This identity crisis reflects the perpetual evolution of pop-punk, as the genre continues to orbit between mainstream pop and punk sensibilities.
Producer Andrew Goldstein sheds light on the inherent similarities between pop and pop-punk that enable crossover success. He notes that both genres often feature simple chord progressions, catchy melodies, and relatable lyrics—elements that resonate with a wide audience. This has allowed artists like Paramore and Fall Out Boy to push the boundaries of pop-punk, often facing backlash from purist fans in the process.
Indeed, when Paramore released the anthemic "That's What You Get" in the mid-2000s, their label initially hesitated, fearing the band was moving too quickly towards pop success. Similarly, Fall Out Boy's decision to embrace a more polished, pop-leaning sound on their 2013 album "Save Rock and Roll" was met with skepticism from some fans. However, these artists' willingness to evolve ultimately paved the way for the next wave of pop-punk acts, including the likes of Olivia Rodrigo and Machine Gun Kelly.
As the pop-punk landscape continues to shift, 5 Seconds of Summer must navigate their own place within the genre, balancing their pop sensibilities with the punk influences that first inspired them. The band's journey reflects the perpetual cycle of pop-punk, where the line between mainstream and underground is constantly blurred, and artists must find the courage to push the genre forward, even in the face of fan resistance.
