Clooney's Suburbicon: Two Movies That Don't Mix

George Clooney's 2017 film, Suburbicon, presents a fractured narrative attempting to intertwine a murder mystery with a poignant exploration of racial prejudice.

Originally conceived by the Coen brothers as a straightforward murder mystery set in an idyllic suburb, the script was later developed by Clooney. He introduced a parallel storyline focusing on a Black family's experience integrating into an all-white neighborhood during the 1950s, confronting significant backlash.

The film centers on the Lodge family, whose matriarch, Rose, is killed during a home invasion. Her identical twin sister, Margaret, subsequently assumes her place, deepening the mystery surrounding the crime and the family's dynamic.

Concurrently, the Mayer family, who are Black, face overt discrimination and hostility from their new neighbors. This societal tension culminates in a riot, starkly contrasting with the unfolding domestic drama and crime at the Lodge residence.

Suburbicon's critical failing lies in its inability to seamlessly merge these two distinct plotlines. The narratives, while compelling individually, feel forced together, diminishing the impact of both the satire and the murder mystery. The resolution feels particularly disjointed, hindering the film's overall effectiveness.

Despite its flaws, the film showcases elements reminiscent of the Coen brothers' distinctive style. However, it ultimately comes across as an underdeveloped concept rather than a fully realized cinematic work, a blend of two disparate visions rushed into production.

As of this reporting, Suburbicon is accessible for free streaming on Pluto TV.