Which awards groups influence Oscar documentary voters?

The Gothams and the New York Film Critics Circle are among the early awards groups that aim to influence Oscar documentary voters.

Are international documentaries favored in the Oscar race?

Yes, international documentaries may have an advantage due to a growing international voting base in the Academy's documentary branch.

What criticism do the Gothams awards face?

The Gothams face criticism for potential 'pay-to-play' awards and a shift away from celebrating independent film.

Home / Arts and Entertainment / Oscar Doc Race: Which Films Will Make the Cut?

Oscar Doc Race: Which Films Will Make the Cut?

5 Dec, 2025

•

Summary

Early awards like the Gothams and NYFCC aim to influence Oscar voters.
The Gothams are criticized for potential pay-to-play and loss of independent film focus.
International films may have an edge in the documentary Oscar race this year.

Oscar Doc Race: Which Films Will Make the Cut?

The race for the Best Feature Documentary Oscar is becoming clearer as early awards like the Gothams and the New York Film Critics Circle (NYFCC) announce their winners. These ceremonies serve to highlight films and influence the approximately 10,000 Oscar voters. The NYFCC, in particular, is considered to have significant prestige and clout among Academy members.

However, the Gothams are facing scrutiny for perceived commercialization, with accusations of "pay-for-play" awards and pressure to favor larger films, potentially undermining their role in celebrating independent cinema. Critics argue that the Gothams no longer solely focus on independent film, especially after removing budget caps.

This year, films with international appeal might possess an advantage in the documentary Oscar race. With a significant portion of the documentary branch now comprising international voters, films like Ukraine war documentary "2000 Meters to Adriivka" and Iran's "Cutting Through Rocks" could gain traction over American-centric narratives.