Who were the NFL stars on The Great American Baking Show's Celebrity Big Game special?

The NFL legends featured on the Celebrity Big Game special included Antonio Gates, Von Miller, and Julian Edelman.

What did the hosts say about comedians versus athletes on the show?

Hosts Casey Wilson and Andrew Rannells observed that comedians are more likely to 'melt down' under the baking show's pressure than the competing athletes.

Where can I watch The Great American Baking Show's Celebrity Big Game special?

The Celebrity Big Game special of The Great American Baking Show is available for free streaming on The Roku Channel.

Home / Arts and Entertainment / NFL Stars Bake Under Pressure on The Great American Baking Show

NFL Stars Bake Under Pressure on The Great American Baking Show

10 Feb

•

Summary

NFL legends competed in a themed episode of The Great American Baking Show.
Hosts noted comedians tend to struggle more than athletes on the show.
The special Celebrity Big Game episode is available for free streaming.

NFL Stars Bake Under Pressure on The Great American Baking Show

The Great American Baking Show recently featured an NFL-themed episode, the "Celebrity Big Game" special, released in early 2026. Hosted by Casey Wilson and Andrew Rannells, the show saw NFL legends Antonio Gates, Von Miller, and Julian Edelman alongside sports analyst Mina Kimes donning aprons. Hosts Wilson and Rannells remarked on how well the athletes managed the pressure in the baking tent, noting that comedians often prove more prone to "melting down" under the circumstances.

This special episode, which aired on The Roku Channel and was available for free streaming, highlighted a different facet of these famous personalities. Rannells, a past competitor, and Wilson have previously hosted other celebrity specials, including "Celebrity Holiday." Their experience suggests that while athletes may be accustomed to intense competition, the baking environment presents a distinct and often humorous challenge, where composure is key.