Why did Kyle Sandilands get stunned on Australian Idol?

Kyle Sandilands was stunned because a contestant named Eva asked the judges to pick her audition song for her.

What did Amy Shark advise Eva during her Australian Idol audition?

Amy Shark advised Eva that she needed to be her own artist.

Were there rumors about Kyle Sandilands leaving Australian Idol?

Yes, in April 2025, there was speculation that Kyle Sandilands would not return for the next season of Australian Idol, which he denied.

Home / Arts and Entertainment / Idol Audition Stunner: Contestant Lets Judges Pick Her Song!

Idol Audition Stunner: Contestant Lets Judges Pick Her Song!

29 Jan

•

Summary

Contestant Eva stunned judges by asking them to choose her audition song.
Kyle Sandilands joked about contestants not having a song as a red flag.
Sandilands previously denied rumors of leaving his Australian Idol role.

Idol Audition Stunner: Contestant Lets Judges Pick Her Song!

On the upcoming season of Australian Idol, judge Kyle Sandilands was momentarily stunned during an audition. Contestant Eva approached the judges, including Amy Shark and Marcia Hines, without a prepared song and requested they choose one for her performance. Sandilands initially reacted with surprise, stating it's usually a 'red flag' when a contestant doesn't have their own song.

Amy Shark agreed, advising Eva to embrace her own artistic identity. The judges playfully suggested songs, with Sandilands humorously offering 'Whitney Houston' and 'Men at Work, Down Under,' while Marcia Hines suggested 'Tennessee Whiskey.' This season's auditions also follow previous speculation in April 2025 that Sandilands might leave his hosting position after his contract ended.