Home / Arts and Entertainment / 3 Idiots' Secret: How Logic Was Bent
3 Idiots' Secret: How Logic Was Bent
22 Nov
Summary
- Filmmakers can take liberties with logic if the audience isn't aware.
- 3 Idiots featured coincidences that would fail screenwriting classes.
- Biopics require 70-80% accuracy with intact core values.

Filmmakers Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi recently discussed the nuanced role of logic in filmmaking. They explained that while logic is crucial, cinematic liberties can be taken, provided they remain undetected by the audience.
Joshi highlighted the 2009 film "3 Idiots" as a prime example, noting its plot contained improbable coincidences, such as multiple critical events occurring on the same day. Despite these logical flaws, the film resonated with viewers because these liberties were cleverly concealed.
Hirani elaborated that the key is not to breach the audience's belief, stating, "If the audience feels 'Yaar, aisa ho nahin sakta', then you've lost the plot." He stressed that all films, to varying degrees, manipulate reality for dramatic effect.
When discussing biopics or films based on real events, Joshi stated that a higher degree of accuracy is required, aiming for 70-80% factual representation while ensuring the core values remain intact. Hirani concurred, noting that even historical films like "Gandhi" might alter timelines for better dramatic presentation, preventing the narrative from becoming monotonous.