Will Spencer Dutton be in the 1944 spinoff?

Brendan Sklenar, who plays Spencer Dutton, has given a coy response, leaving his return uncertain.

When is the Yellowstone '1944' prequel coming out?

The release date for the '1944' prequel spinoff has not yet been announced as of December 2025.

Why haven't we heard about Taylor Sheridan's '1944' spinoff?

Taylor Sheridan's shifting development deals and studio changes may be affecting updates on the '1944' prequel.

Home / Arts and Entertainment / Dutton Spinoff '1944' Secrets: Spencer Dutton's Return Unclear

Dutton Spinoff '1944' Secrets: Spencer Dutton's Return Unclear

9 Dec, 2025

•

Summary

The '1944' prequel spinoff's status remains uncertain as of December 2025.
Brendan Sklenar, who plays Spencer Dutton, gave a coy response about returning.
Taylor Sheridan's deal shift may impact Paramount's involvement with '1944'.

Dutton Spinoff '1944' Secrets: Spencer Dutton's Return Unclear

The much-anticipated '1944' prequel spinoff, part of the Dutton family saga, faces an uncertain future. As of December 2025, details are scarce, leaving fans to hope for the return of Brendan Sklenar's Spencer Dutton. Sklenar himself gave an ambiguous and lighthearted answer when questioned about his involvement, adding to the mystery surrounding the project.

Recent developments suggest a potential reason for the silence. Taylor Sheridan's move to NBCUniversal for future projects could impact his existing commitments with Paramount, the studio reportedly overseeing '1944'. This transition raises questions about whether the story expansion will proceed with the original network.

Ultimately, the clarity on Spencer Dutton's future and the '1944' prequel hinges on creator Taylor Sheridan. Until he provides an update, fans are left to speculate, especially as Sklenar promotes other upcoming work, hoping for definitive news soon.