Colton Underwood's Past Haunts Reality TV Comeback

Colton Underwood's participation in the fourth season of Peacock's The Traitors has brought renewed scrutiny to past allegations of stalking and harassment made by his ex-girlfriend, Cassie Randolph. Randolph had filed a temporary restraining order in September 2020, claiming Underwood planted a tracking device on her car and showed up unannounced at her home and parents' residence. Though the restraining order was dismissed two months later following a private agreement, the allegations have resurfaced with Underwood's return to reality television.

Insiders suggest that Underwood's appearance on The Traitors is a calculated move to regain public favor, with one source stating, 'He's very self-focused. Everything is calculated to what can make him look the best.' This perspective contrasts with Underwood's own statements where he has apologized for past mistakes and taken accountability, stating he was in a 'dark place' and has worked on growth. However, critics like former Bachelor contestant Demi Burnett believe Underwood's return is solely for attention, and that his coming out as gay in 2021 was a deflection from the restraining order scandal.

The renewed interest has also led to confrontations, notably with co-star Lisa Rinna, who directly questioned Underwood about his past at the show's reunion. While Underwood denied storming off the set, calling it a planned break, the tension highlights the ongoing controversy surrounding him. Underwood himself has acknowledged the backlash and online bullying, including death threats, but maintains he has apologized and taken responsibility for his actions.