BBC Casting Criticized for 'Clunky' Diversity

A recent independent report has raised concerns regarding the BBC's casting practices, particularly in historical dramas and period pieces. The review suggests that while aiming for diversity, the broadcaster's choices can appear "clunky" and "tokenistic" when not carefully considered.

Specific examples cited include the casting of mixed-race actors in roles such as Sir Isaac Newton in Doctor Who and Estella in Great Expectations, a 19th-century story. The report questions whether such anachronistic casting serves authenticity or inadvertently erases historical struggles of ethnic minorities.

However, the review also acknowledges that exclusively casting white actors in period dramas risks ignoring the historical presence of ethnic minorities in Britain. It notes that 'colour-blind casting' can also broaden opportunities for actors of color.

The report further addresses the BBC's portrayal of the working class, suggesting an overreliance on themes of crime and addiction. It also criticizes the broadcaster's heavy concentration of content creation, casting, and news broadcasts in London.

The review recommends a greater focus on regions outside of the south of England and the devolved nations. It advocates for more senior decision-makers to be located outside the capital to ensure more authentic and geographically rooted content.

Additionally, the report calls for improved gender balance, particularly among older presenters and contributors in news and factual programming. The BBC chairman acknowledged the need for authentic reflection of all communities and classes across the UK.