Home / Arts and Entertainment / Writer Slams Star Trek Shows as "Shit"
Writer Slams Star Trek Shows as "Shit"
30 Mar
Summary
- Writer Andy Weir called Star Trek shows "shit" after pitch rejection.
- Writer Don Winslow defended Alex Kurtzman against Weir's comments.
- Weir's critique came after a pitch was turned down by Kurtzman.

Author Andy Weir recently voiced harsh criticism of the current Star Trek television shows, labeling them "shit" during a podcast appearance. Weir stated that his pitch for a Star Trek series was rejected by executive producer Alex Kurtzman, whom he described as a "nice guy." This public commentary has drawn a strong reaction from writer Don Winslow.
Winslow took to social media to defend Kurtzman, calling him a "visionary writer, creator, producer" and stating Weir owes him an apology. Winslow highlighted the principle of writers supporting each other, a concept central to the formation of the Writers Guild. He asserted that writers should not use their success to disparage the work of others.
Weir, known for "The Martian" and "Project Hail Mary," made his controversial remarks shortly after it was announced that "Starfleet Academy" would conclude after its second season. Production on "Strange New Worlds" has also wrapped its latest season, both of which are overseen by Kurtzman's Secret Hideout label.