Amanda Stanton Reveals Josh Murray's Controlling Behavior

Amanda Stanton has disclosed further insights into the dissolution of her engagement to Josh Murray, which followed the third season of Bachelor in Paradise. Speaking on the "Comeback Era Podcast" on October 23, 2026, Stanton, 36, recalled experiencing early signs that the relationship would not succeed. She specifically mentioned a temper tantrum exhibited by Murray during the show.

Upon returning home before the season's broadcast, Stanton observed additional concerning behaviors, including a lack of trust from Murray. She informed the show's executive producer of her doubts, though she felt obligated to proceed with the engagement. Stanton, who was a single mother at the time, stated that Murray's actions felt controlling and threatened her sense of freedom.

This led to their initial split in December 2016, followed by a brief reconciliation. They permanently ended their relationship in February 2017. Stanton's 2019 memoir, "Now Accepting Roses," also detailed Murray's controlling nature during filming, noting his disapproval of her interactions with friends and neighbors.