How were the 30 greatest living American songwriters chosen?

The selection involved polling hundreds of experts, followed by weeks of deliberation and debate among Times-affiliated critics to define greatness and narrow down the nominees.

Who are some examples of the greatest living American songwriters?

The list includes artists across generations, such as the elder statesman Willie Nelson and contemporary artist Bad Bunny, reflecting a wide range of musical styles.

What criteria were used to define songwriting greatness?

Critics debated factors like originality, influence, mass appeal, irony, grandeur, idiosyncrasy, political consciousness, personal confession, formal mastery, and disruption.

Home / Arts and Entertainment / America's 30 Best Living Songwriters Revealed

America's 30 Best Living Songwriters Revealed

28 Apr

•

Summary

Experts and critics debated greatness in American music.
The list spans generations, from Willie Nelson to Bad Bunny.
It reflects diverse influences and songwriting approaches.

America's 30 Best Living Songwriters Revealed

Hundreds of experts and critics meticulously debated to determine the 30 greatest living American songwriters, reflecting a vast and varied musical landscape.

The selection process involved expert ballots followed by in-depth discussions among Times-affiliated critics, leading to passionate debates about musical criteria.

The final list spans generations, featuring artists like Willie Nelson, born in 1933, and Bad Bunny, a product of 1990s San Juan.